The books I read during the IPL

Archive for April, 2013

The Hungry Tide – Amitav Ghosh



The Hungry Tide – Amitav Ghosh


Like so many people who have taken interest in this book review project, a Bengali friend was quick to recommend a book when she heard of this blog. The Hungry Tide is the story of human interaction and the interaction of humans with the harshness and beauty of nature. It shows the contrast of opinion and action of a variety of characters from differing backgrounds and in the face of different circumstances . After a pretty slow start the novel gathers pace and becomes the cliched page turner.


It is set in the Sundarbans, a mystic area of natural beauty right on the doorstep of Kolkata. The area has been mentioned to me on many occasions and I thought a story set in this place would be insightful. It turned out to be an incredibly written story that is both complex and easy to follow. The mixture of the islands physical make up , it’s wildlife, it’s culture and the waters that surround it provide the perfect setting for the unravelling of this story.


The story is told through the visits of Kanai and Piyali to the Sunderbans. They have a chance meeting in Kolkata before going their separate ways. Piyali (of Bengali descent) is an American post grad student who has travelled to the Sunderbans to research it’s dolphin population. She is thrown into the path of a local fisherman who saves her life and despite the lack of sharing a common language these two have a connection that transcends the communication of tongues. Trust, equality, respect and understanding are played out in this speechless relationship.


Kanai is a linguist and owner of a translation agency. He is in the area to review the writings of his late uncle. These writings are in themselves a separate story of a people’s struggle against the Indian government for settlement in a previously uninhabited island of the area. It is a heartening tale of displacement and the triumph of the human spirit in the search for belonging. It is a factual account of the establishment of a society based on the utopian principles of an English Humanist, Sir Daniel Hamilton . These papers end up revealing the story of Kusum and her young son Fokir, the very same boatman who later saves Piya’s life. Languages, translations, and understanding are a common theme throughout the book and Kanai’s vocation adds an ironic element to the story. 


Piya and Kanai, after going there seperate ways are reunited in Lusabari. Fokir is also enlisted to help with Piya’s research and an air of tension arises on the trip.Kanai is arrogant, Fokir although illiterate is soulful and genuine. The contrast is revealing of the differences in human nature. While Kanai’s education and sophistication are revered in the city, it is the people of the islands who are the masters of the tide country.


The book is a compilation of short chapters. The chapters jump back and forth in time and  place, constantly keeping you on edge as to how each story is developing. I really like this use of style as you also progressively see how the the different stories are linked. I was constantly trying to put it all together, with more or less succes at different times, like putting a puzzle together. It keeps the mind guessing as to the direction in which the story is headed and the author reveals more and more like a regulating valve. It keeps the plot interesting throughout.


The Hungry Tide is factual and informative. Ghosh is a celebrated academic and his research is meticulous. Information about the partition, war, politics, gender and class struggle, nature conservation, the make up and flaura of the islands, it’s animals , the working of the tides, and Indian folklore are richly interwoven with the telling of this story. The descriptive writing appeals to the senses and this makes the reader feel that they are in the thick of the story. I would highly recommend this book. 


The Kite Runner

woodland group logo kite runner

The Kite Runner

“It’s wrong what they say about the past, I’ve learned, about how you can bury it. Because the past claws it’s way out.” The Kite Runner is the story of the search for atonement by a middle aged man who is smacked by the realization of his errors and the constant reminder that the past catches up with you until you have made amends for your mistakes. Like an evangelist I get the urge to want to distribute this book to everyone I know (and don’t know) every time I read it.

The story unfolds in pre war Afghanistan and is centred around the relationship between Amir, the son of a wealthy businessman, and his servants son Hassan. It takes some vivid imagining to comprehend how Afghanistan once was. The images we see today and it’s recent troubled history make it almost impossible to imagine the idyllic upbringing that Amir and Hassan initially share. Hosseini paints a romantic picture of childhood before taking us through Afghanistan’s transition from a Monarch to a Republic to the destructive rule of the Taliban. The juxtaposition of Hosseini’s original depiction of childhood is made all the more poignant by the fact that this is now lost. “There are a lot of children in Afghanistan, but little childhood.”

The story is narrated by Amir. Despite his evil ways and him being an unlikeable character, this method of narration not only gives a very personal account of what it is like to experience war first hand, but also adds to the anguish one feels when reading about the destruction and devastation which war brings to an individual. It is however far more than a story about one boy’s experience in the war.

It is a richly descriptive story of contrasts: of the rich and the poor, of the master and the servant; of the educated and the illiterate; of the weak and the brave; but ultimately of loyalty and betrayal. The book will reach into the heart of even the hardest of men and is full of lessons on humanity and of the requirements needed for the most basic respect of others.

Cowardice and bravery are recurring themes. At a border checkpoint an exchange between a Russian soldier and Baba, Amir’s father, leaves my heart in my mouth. Baba comes to the rescue of a woman whom the soldier wishes to rape as the price for passing. It is an intense exchange in the most uncomfortable of positions.  On the soldier’s theory that war has no shame Baba replies: “War doesn’t negate decency.It demands it, even more than in times of peace”. Moments later in a hopeless position of despair and weakness and at the threat at being shot for intervening Baba says: ‘Tell him I’ll take a thousand of his bullets before I let this indecency take place’

The book is littered with such exquisitely written passages with profound life lessons. A subtle sense of irony pervades the story. But rather than conveying these lessons in a Shakesperean or Dickensian way, Hosseini brings a fresh approach to prose, while maintaining the literary beauty for which his predecessors are so well known. I cannot think of another writer to compare this piece of work with.

It is also easy to relate to the story. We all have situations which we wish we had handled better and its often easier to will them away by filing rather than confronting them. Bullying is a topical issue in many countries and the book addresses the kind of situations that divide people into bullies and victims. We fail to see it as kids, to paraphrase Kanye West: The people highest up have the lowest self esteem, the most beautiful people do the ugliest things. This book would serve a great purpose in school curriculums the world over.

Hosseini gives Amir a voice that suggests he is truly sorry for what he did. Amir also shows an awareness of just how loyal a friend Hassan was by the stories he recalls and the tone he uses in unveiling what happened. Despite this I still felt anger rather than sorrow for this Amir, right up till the end of the book. The author makes you confront the emotions he evokes.

I generally like books for a variety of three reasons: the story line; the style of writing and use of vocabulary; or the knowledge the author imparts to the reader. You will invariably find one, and its not uncommon to find a combination of two of these traits in a book,but in The Kite Runner Khaled Hosseini has managed to master all three departments. This is why I consider this to be my favourite book.

Calcutta: Two Years in the City by Amit Chaudhuri – review

woodland group logoImage

When I decided to undertake this fund raising I turned to a trusted friend and colleague at KKR. He not only threw himself into helping me, he also suggested and presented me with this first book. He’s got to know my reading preferences and particularly my strong like for non fiction books. I was excited when he briefed me on its content and even more excited when I saw my hard copy was a bright pink colour.

Calcutta is a personal account of two years in the Capital city of West Bengal.  Although born in Calcutta Amit Chaudhuri grew up in Bombay and later moved to the UK. On returning to Calcutta in 1999 he felt the city had lost the charm he remembered when holidaying there as a boy. “It wasn’t just that the relentless departure of capital, of its intelligentsia and middle class, had left it hollowed from inside; it was also the way local politics had territorialised it. ” But in 2009, on the verge of political change and the hope  that comes with it, Chaudhuri felt the time was right to explore the city and the reasons for him becoming a ‘reluctant citizen’ in the city that once enchanted him. The book is written in real time, noting the changes as they happen.

It is a personal memoir in which the author uses the City of Joy as his vehicle. I only really get to see small parts of the city from my seat on the team bus, but I can agree with the statement ‘You feel that something happened here’. You get the feeling that Calcutta failed to progress from it’s once greatness.The authors mood changes from upbeat excitement to disappointment and nostalgia as he ventures from the Calcutta of his youth to the  Kolkata he returns too as an adult.

I grew up in Port Elizabeth, and on returning to that city as an adult (after a 10 year absence) also felt disappointed. I can relate to Mr Chaudhuri’s feelings but am wondering if this is not more a reflection of the changing expectations of the individual rather than the decline of the city. After experiencing the diverse atmospheres, cultures, architecture and cuisine of other cities, surely a return to your city of birth could seem disappointing?

Mr Chaudhuri does give plausible causes for the perceived decline of the cities fortunes. Political beuracracy and political decision making are regularly visited topics in the book. ‘It was the usual story of the time: this gradual emptying of the city of commerce; the absolute reign over it of what it had always harboured – politics. ‘ It is however far more than a political history of the city.’

The book is a waffle, but a good flowing waffle. His writing is full of unexpected digressions, full of surprises and constantly changes direction in ways you don’t expect. By choosing to write in this way Chaudhuri has the freedom to cover a wide range of topics. He uses a mixture of rich text and quirky commentary to make the most mundane objects, personal interactions, and routine occurrences seem fascinating. The digression away from Calcutta-specific topics keeps the writing fresh and the reader interested. It also satisfies the appetite for knowledge over a wide area of interests.

Chaudhuri’s book is populated by a rich cast of characters, varying across social strata, religious beliefs and heritage , reflecting his depiction of Calcutta as a melting pot of cultures. Relating anecdotes about individuals he has encountered allows the author to use Calcutta’s wide range of inhabitants as different platforms from which to explore the city.

My most enjoyable part of the book was Chapter 2, Chandan Hotel.  The author vividly describes a part of the city that I am very familiar with; “The stalls are squalid, a small universe of cooking pots, potato peels, benches, and a few people absently lolling under the shelter of a tarpaulin” and ” even now, when its supposed to have been phased out of the city’s traffic, the hand-pulled rickshaw rolls onward, with an imperious shopper afloat.” By interviewing and observing the ‘citizens’ of Park Street and the adjoining Free School Road he brings the area with its narrow alleys and it’s informal economy to life.  I felt and fulfilled the urge to jump in a cab and get down there after reading this chapter.

The contrast between the local informal eateries of free school street ( “tiny cauliflower florets,their tips rusted like dry blood. This snack costs a paltry two rupees a plate “) and the refurbished restaurants of Park Street where tourists, much like myself, watch people toing and froing through the large modern glass windows of restaurants that charge London prices for a meal. ” Park Street is neither Oxford Street nor the Champs-Élysées, but here, in the stretch between Chowringhee and the junction of Free School Street and Middleton Row, it has an energy comparable to no other downtown district that I know. ”

One negative is the constant use of complicated vocabulary which I think would scare off readers with a less than excellent handle of the English language. (Chaudhuri studied at Cambridge). I had to look up the meaning of many words and while I personally found the exercise interesting and insightful I feel that it will prevent many readers from enjoying this unique account of this fascinating city.

If you don’t mind consulting a dictionary, or preferably have an extensive vocabulary, then I have no doubt that you will enjoy the book’s mixture of facts and excellently written opinions.It could even captivate the imagination enough to  make you want to explore the places that are the centre of this story of the City of Joy.


woodland group logotendoblog

Welcome to my book review blog.

I’m undertaking to read and review one book a week during the course of the IPL. I don’t profess to be a literary genius or of having any standout intellectual qualities  and I’m sure my style of review will portray this. I want to give my interpretation, my opinion, and my personal connections to the books I read.

I always enjoyed reading as a child. I guess a crowded sports schedule (and maybe – if im tough enough to admit- some peer pressure) took me away from this pastime from about the age of 13.  I suddenly rediscovered the passion about 5 years ago and have made up for lost time. I’ve also undergone a personal enlightenment and my thirst for knowledge and for exploring new spheres increases with my age. To paraphrase Hitchins, this thirst has led me to realise that I know less and less- but I at least know less and less about more and more.

To the meat of the matter- I’m using this platform to raise awareness for reading, and more importantly for the need for education in underprivileged areas. My plan is – with the help of some selfless people- to raise money to build a library or two in India. I have little experience so we’ll start with small expectations but we do have a reachable figure in mind.

I got introduced to Room to Read when I went along to the opening of a library at a school in Delhi through my association with the ICC as I was playing in the 2011 Cricket World Cup in India.

That day was an eye opener and after reading up on the organisation and its work I wanted to get involved. I also read Leaving Microsoft to Change the World! The inspiring story of the charity’s founder and his process to grow the charity into the respected organisation it has become. Please check out

I hope you enjoy this blog and look forward to comments, suggestions, questions and most importantly to spreading the joy of reading.